Reviews from

Old Oak Tree

An old tree I climbed to watch for Indian attack.

3 total reviews 
Comment from nor84
Good
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I wanted to give you a heads-up. The rules say: This is a free verse poetry contest. Any poem about any subject verse or specific syllable count isn't needed.

However, free verse poems cannot have an established rhyme scheme as this one does. You still may have time to fix it.

 Comment Written 01-Feb-2020


reply by the author on 03-Feb-2020
    Thanks much.
Comment from Suzanna Ray
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Dear Author, Thank you for bringing back memories like this for me! I wasn't watching for Indian attack's, and my tree wasn't an Oak, but the sentiments about 'going back' had tears flowing out of these elderly eyes.
Poetry can say things that regular words cannot. Is it because of the rhymes or the flow of metered words that make the difference. Have you ever tried to figure it out?

 Comment Written 20-Jan-2020


reply by the author on 20-Jan-2020
    Thank you Suzanna. I'm 82 and as I get older I think of my young years much more. They were poor years, but good years. I agree,
    poetry is much more expressive than free verse
reply by Suzanna Ray on 21-Jan-2020
    Hey! we are the same age! Do you write Prose on FanStory too?
Comment from Mary Kay Bonfante
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Beautiful, heartwarming poem about a precious childhood memory and a place with a history that goes back in the family for generations. Even though it's free verse, I like the rhymes. I can picture the majestic oak tree and the young boy climbing it, looking out for marauding Indians. Just precious!

 Comment Written 20-Jan-2020


reply by the author on 20-Jan-2020
    Thank you Mary for the very nice comments. It will probably be rejected, but that doesn't matter. I write for the reviews I receive
    not the contest. Thank you, for the stars.
reply by Mary Kay Bonfante on 20-Jan-2020
    You're very welcome. I don't think not winning a contest means a work is rejected - I've entered several contests already, and I just figure there's a lot of competition. You really have a beautiful poem there. It wouldn't hurt to win sometime, but we keep going anyway! I'm glad you do too.