Reviews from

From out of the Grayness

Viewing comments for Chapter 17 "Star Chasing by: His Grayness"
Reaching from the gray areas to understand life

14 total reviews 
Comment from Eleanor Buron
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

A fine tribute to Gert Sherwood! The poem sings its message - good rhyming and good rhythm. I totally agree with the message too - gratitude not attitude. You got the message across strong and clear - in a friendly persuasive way that all can appreciate.

 Comment Written 04-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 05-Dec-2013
    Dear Eleanor: Your review is very encouraging and received with deep gratitude! It's always a genuine pleasure to hear from you as your wisdom and talent is certainly profound! Vance
Comment from Gert sherwood
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

I like your thoughts Vance when you said-

it's the passion of spilling our heart.
In hopes that our friendships shall not drift apart.
If only one single star or even a tiny few,
Comes graciously in from a reader
as a meaningful review

Let me answer with a free verse poem I wrote here on Fanstory-- years ago about why I write poetry--

I do not know when I have had
happier times in my soul,
than when I have been sitting at work,
with nothing before me but my mouse
and computer, and hearing
no sound but that of the clicking
keyboard, with God in my soul
and the light of my monitor
in my eyes~~ I am happy doing
what I like best and what I can
as long as God helps me to write.

I do get up and take a rest for a while
to look out the window, and gaze
upon the stars in the skies
I think once more of the grandeur of earth,
then return to my work, aware that I am
surely one of the happiest beings alive.

Being able to view the celestial Heavens

Written by Gert







 Comment Written 04-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 04-Dec-2013
    Oh, Dear Gert...what a wonderful and simply splendid message!
    Thanks so much for sharing this work. I hope your time of rest will spark even more of these generous words. Blessings! Vance
reply by Gert sherwood on 04-Dec-2013
    You are so welcome Vance
    Take care.

    Gert
Comment from bgcnorth
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Very esoteric. Something to chew on. Line 14..is it supposed to be "to lay OUT their hearts..." It says "to lay our their hearts. You have such a wonderful grasp of rhyme and rythmn and it dances throughout this writing.

 Comment Written 03-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 04-Dec-2013
    Thank you sincerely for your generous comments and I will edit that error you've wisely discovered. Many thanks for that. Have a wonderful day and I hope to connect with you again soon! Vance
Comment from KinaSalad
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Hi there His Grayness, I enjoyed reading through your poem and if I didn't, I wouldn't be writing this review. So thanks very much for sharing

 Comment Written 03-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 03-Dec-2013
    Well said and much appreciated! I'ts a pleasure to hear from you and hope we shall connect again soon. All the best to you! Vance
Comment from Tatarka2
Good
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I loved this as a tribute to your friend. I'd look it over again for SPAGS (someone's; the whole second line - though, may be). I'd also look over the last two lines - "comes graciously in -- ". These two lines seem too long to me and don't seem to flow lyrically with the rest of the poem. Overall, though, I love your message, and I would like to think that I do get it. I'm sure so many readers will, as well. As it stands, it's a little difficult to read - I had to go over it three times to really take in the meaning. I think just a couple of quick re-writes can fix this, and you'll have a very powerful message.

 Comment Written 03-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 03-Dec-2013
    Dear Tatarka2: your comments and suggestions are greatly appreciated and I'm grateful for the time and mind you have invested in this review. Kindest regards, His Grayness: Vance
Comment from MERRY1
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

love your attitude and your poem. we write because we have something to get out of our system I feel. the stars can shine as bright as they like and are appreciated but it is the love of putting pen to paper that is the thrill. small error in line two you left out 'not be' I think. well done

 Comment Written 03-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 03-Dec-2013
    Thanks so much MERRY1...I shall review as you suggested and your comments are gratefully taken. I hope to share with you again in the near future: HIS GRAYNESS: Vance
Comment from michaelcahill
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

So very well put. It is about the writing after all. The incentives and stars and all of that are nice and do help make everything run I suppose. But, we should never lose the joy of a fine piece of work. We should never pass over a heartfelt cry for understanding from a fellow artist. If anyone should understand what it is like to feel things the way an artist does certainly it is another artist. A wonderful piece. Not surprising that it comes from you. Well done, mikey

 Comment Written 03-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 03-Dec-2013
    Hey Mikey: I'm challenged to express how deeply I appreciate your words of encouragement here and how joyful it is to know that there are like-minded missions of love, joy, and true gratitude in consideration for and by others...especially POETS! Blessings! Vance
Comment from val fitchie
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

could starchasers ALSO be addressing the reviewers that only do it for the meaningless "reviewer levels" here? I will go to my grave sulking that I couldn't "contribute" here-(I'm poor and it would have been no skin off their noses to give incentive to people like me who are PASSIONATE and SINCERE and SUPPORTIVE of the ARTS and ARTISTS)Yet,I am STILL hanging around here STAR gazing...at that BRILLIANT constellation of THOUGHT and FEELING known as HIS GREYNESS...HE is my REWARD for reviewing. I am his reward for beautiful ugly truth. And ya know what? It is ALL FREELY GIVEN -no need to "chase" This man has 'EARNED' my respect the good old fashioned way

 Comment Written 02-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 03-Dec-2013
    Dear Val: your wise and insightful message does parallel my mission of this poem as it is especially clear that YOUR UNIQUE and BRILLIANT method and passion of reviewing is fully intended to provide perspective, contrast, grip/power/impact, and overall measurement of VALUE. Those critical values are what you GUIDE writers to and therefore, the stars will REFLECT appropriately how they are winning these objectives. I'm sure that was the sincere and ethical intention of FANSTORY.COM and NOT that they would endorse or intend any 'Vanity Fair'. I've never had the skill to achieve six stars from you and believe me...I honor that challenge with the full integrity behind it. Vance
reply by val fitchie on 03-Dec-2013
    computer was acting goofy-just checking to see if you got my reply concerning 5s and 6s
Comment from tbacha58
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

To lay our their hearts and to capture a vision.
I'm here out of love and to give what I may.
To improve someone' life for forever or a day.

My dearest Vance, your poem, made me even more proud of you, you are such an amazing person, full of love, giving, understanding, protecting, harmless, faithful, sincere, generous, you are the whole universe that is the best part in you. I loved loved the way you wrote that poem, because you did change something in my life, you are right, you are here for a reason, and we all are here for a reason, is to love protect, and share. You are a wonderful gentleman, I knew that from day one, you stood by me, when I was in terrible pain, and I wrote the poem to get rid of how much I was hurt. I thank you from the depth of my heart Vance, I am honored to have met you, and love FS even more because of you and many other friends I have here now. They listen to me, they share, they help me survive. God Bless you my friend. I wish you all the happiness and success , and health. We will keep in touch. Hugs Love. Terry xoxoxo

 Comment Written 02-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 03-Dec-2013
    Dearest Terry: the emotions we share are genuine for their intentions are pure and I believe they endorse the lessons that GOD wants us to understand in loving and caring for each other...and THEREIN recognizing the joy and GRATITUDE we experience as we follow HIS guidance! It is all about the honest GRATITUDE AT HAND AT THIS MOMENT! Making it permanent it the REAL challenge and only exchanging love and appreciation at all times can keep it alive. Blessings to you dear friend! Vance
Comment from reconciled
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Hey Dad...well this is certainly cool...-smile-...chasing stars...pre-occupation in a never ending human race. the star system was designed to attracted attention....everyone.....everyone who writes...covets the pretty girl in schools notice....or the neighbors new ford....hopes for the gold for their effort...I don't know that pretending any other would be honest. Now....to write....what you feel is important....un...or visions seen in dreams of faithless surrender....is the writers prerogative ...in a free society. I am a fan of motivation...and those who inspire it......but in my experience those that inspire best get dressed in honesty. ....my point ....if all you write is inspiration......those who cant find it ....will see you as unreal. K....see you later love you Michael

 Comment Written 02-Dec-2013


reply by the author on 03-Dec-2013
    Dear Son, Michael: as you know, I consider you an Extraordinarily BRILLIANT AND GIFTED writer with more scope of thought than the average zillion people who ever touch a pen. I find no criticisms in anyone who reaches for a wink, not, a pat upon (any body part)as acknowledgement that have GIVEN something of meaning and value to another. Inspiration Hope, Joy, GRATITUDE are the richest of these gifts. Entertainment is fun and brings joy and it's own form of GRATITUDE which the my REAL Target of my work: the emotions we share are genuine for their intentions are pure and I believe they endorse the lessons that GOD wants us to understand in loving and caring for each other...and THEREIN recognizing the joy and GRATITUDE we experience as we follow HIS guidance! It is all about the honest GRATITUDE AT HAND AT THIS MOMENT! Making it permanent it the REAL challenge and only exchanging love and appreciation at all times can keep it alive. Blessings to you dear son!! Love Dad