Secrets in the Wind
Viewing comments for Chapter 43 "Secrets in the Wind - Chap 43"A story of loss, deceit, murder and crime
19 total reviews
Comment from karenina
Zing! Liz truly was secretly unhappy, and told Jack! She must have been feeling responsible since the crash...hence, redirecting others with her wondering if Jack had been smitten with another woman? Amazing no one has thought to look at the coroner's report! Hmmm. How/why did Miguel appear so suddenly!? Another "secret" to unravel... Amy's name has been dropped. A red herring? I put nothing past you! Where's Annie!? (You're killing me here)--
Also, awaiting the "family reunion" -- wow.
I'm ready and buckled in! Crisp concise dialogue!
Karenina
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
  |
Zing! Liz truly was secretly unhappy, and told Jack! She must have been feeling responsible since the crash...hence, redirecting others with her wondering if Jack had been smitten with another woman? Amazing no one has thought to look at the coroner's report! Hmmm. How/why did Miguel appear so suddenly!? Another "secret" to unravel... Amy's name has been dropped. A red herring? I put nothing past you! Where's Annie!? (You're killing me here)--
Also, awaiting the "family reunion" -- wow.
I'm ready and buckled in! Crisp concise dialogue!
Karenina
Comment Written 04-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
if I every finish these responses, I will write the confrontation between Mary and Jon and then hopefully move to the girls meeting each other. Make sure you tell me if I am off on any parts of the emotions or the story...Smiles, Carol
-
I will, promise.... Karenina
Comment from lyenochka
Oh, does Liz know that her name is Hope? I wonder why she had such a terrible reaction to Mary? Good background information here given through dialogue so it goes fast.
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
Oh, does Liz know that her name is Hope? I wonder why she had such a terrible reaction to Mary? Good background information here given through dialogue so it goes fast.
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Sorry for the cut and paste but I am now currently 158 responses behind. I want to make the changes, thank everyone and start fresh. Wishing you a great day.
Please forgive me for being so far behind on answering reviews, fixing suggestions, and thanking everyone for their kindness. Good thing a birthday only comes once a year. I posted to my family that I was cooking and for the first time in years, my house was over flowing for two days after two days of cooking. Now in three days, Matthew starts filming again and I must cook for them. This woman is tired. Thank you for all your support and kindness.
Smiles, Carol
Comment from Mary Kay Bonfante
I'm so glad that Liz has Allie to confide in. She really needs a friend right now. Apparently her fear that she "killed" Jack is one of the "secrets in the wind." (Great title, by the way.)
Errors and suggestions:
Liz squeezed her eyes closed, inhaled before looking at Allie again.
-->
Liz squeezed her eyes closed, and inhaled before looking at Allie again.
"Well, let's get and see.
-->
"Well, let's get it and see.
In your summary:
Mary, a caregiver, discovers her child she gave up for adoption thirty years ago. Cynthia and Michael are searching for gold on Liz's property. The mysterious woman (Faith) is dying from cancer and lives in a secret cottage with her daughter, Annie, Sebastion, and Mary.
-->
Mary, a caregiver, discovers her child she gave up for adoption thirty years ago. The mysterious woman (Faith) is dying from cancer and lives in a secret cottage with her daughter, Annie, Sebastian, and Mary. Cynthia and Michael are searching for gold on Liz's property. [correcting the spelling of "Sebastian" and ordering the sentences so that the material about Mary appears together]
***
You really piqued my curiosity, when Liz mentioned Amy calling her about the party she missed, before Jack was killed. What was that about? And now we need to know about the coroner's report about Jack... and what Liz will say about Hope, who we know is really Liz. Plenty of secrets you have lined up for us, Carol! You're getting very good at this!
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
I'm so glad that Liz has Allie to confide in. She really needs a friend right now. Apparently her fear that she "killed" Jack is one of the "secrets in the wind." (Great title, by the way.)
Errors and suggestions:
Liz squeezed her eyes closed, inhaled before looking at Allie again.
-->
Liz squeezed her eyes closed, and inhaled before looking at Allie again.
"Well, let's get and see.
-->
"Well, let's get it and see.
In your summary:
Mary, a caregiver, discovers her child she gave up for adoption thirty years ago. Cynthia and Michael are searching for gold on Liz's property. The mysterious woman (Faith) is dying from cancer and lives in a secret cottage with her daughter, Annie, Sebastion, and Mary.
-->
Mary, a caregiver, discovers her child she gave up for adoption thirty years ago. The mysterious woman (Faith) is dying from cancer and lives in a secret cottage with her daughter, Annie, Sebastian, and Mary. Cynthia and Michael are searching for gold on Liz's property. [correcting the spelling of "Sebastian" and ordering the sentences so that the material about Mary appears together]
***
You really piqued my curiosity, when Liz mentioned Amy calling her about the party she missed, before Jack was killed. What was that about? And now we need to know about the coroner's report about Jack... and what Liz will say about Hope, who we know is really Liz. Plenty of secrets you have lined up for us, Carol! You're getting very good at this!
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Sorry for the cut and paste but I am now currently 158 responses behind. I want to make the changes, thank everyone and start fresh. Wishing you a great day.
Please forgive me for being so far behind on answering reviews, fixing suggestions, and thanking everyone for their kindness. Good thing a birthday only comes once a year. I posted to my family that I was cooking and for the first time in years, my house was over flowing for two days after two days of cooking. Now in three days, Matthew starts filming again and I must cook for them. This woman is tired. Thank you for all your support and kindness.
Smiles, Carol
-
You're in my prayers, Carol -- you and your family. There's no need to reply to this message; I know you're very busy right now. God bless you, my friend.
Love, Mary Kay xoxo
Comment from Wendy G
I didn't see this coming at all! So she felt guilty about Jack's death for this reason, and not because she was worried about him having an affair with an "unknown woman" on the property. I hope that she won't consider selling now, so she can go back to the city. Liz seems to have worked out a connection with Hope also, from the other conversation. Looking forward to the next gripping instalment.
Wendy
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
I didn't see this coming at all! So she felt guilty about Jack's death for this reason, and not because she was worried about him having an affair with an "unknown woman" on the property. I hope that she won't consider selling now, so she can go back to the city. Liz seems to have worked out a connection with Hope also, from the other conversation. Looking forward to the next gripping instalment.
Wendy
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Sorry for the cut and paste but I am now currently 158 responses behind. I want to make the changes, thank everyone and start fresh. Wishing you a great day.
Please forgive me for being so far behind on answering reviews, fixing suggestions, and thanking everyone for their kindness. Good thing a birthday only comes once a year. I posted to my family that I was cooking and for the first time in years, my house was over flowing for two days after two days of cooking. Now in three days, Matthew starts filming again and I must cook for them. This woman is tired. Thank you for all your support and kindness.
Smiles, Carol
Comment from Elizabeth Emerald
Intense interaction is spot-on. Stunning backstory--I thought you'd said before that Liz felt guilty because she'd accused Jack of having an affair. I thought when LIZ read the documents after his death about his life being in danger that she assumed his plane had been sabotaged. Why does she now wonder if his fatal crash is on account of being distraught over her wanting to go back to NY? Notwithstanding my confusion, this is gripping!
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
Intense interaction is spot-on. Stunning backstory--I thought you'd said before that Liz felt guilty because she'd accused Jack of having an affair. I thought when LIZ read the documents after his death about his life being in danger that she assumed his plane had been sabotaged. Why does she now wonder if his fatal crash is on account of being distraught over her wanting to go back to NY? Notwithstanding my confusion, this is gripping!
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Sorry for the cut and paste but I am now currently 158 responses behind. I want to make the changes, thank everyone and start fresh. Wishing you a great day.
Please forgive me for being so far behind on answering reviews, fixing suggestions, and thanking everyone for their kindness. Good thing a birthday only comes once a year. I posted to my family that I was cooking and for the first time in years, my house was over flowing for two days after two days of cooking. Now in three days, Matthew starts filming again and I must cook for them. This woman is tired. Thank you for all your support and kindness.
Smiles, Carol
Comment from lancellot
That a was a good and thorough conversation. Liz and Allie are really there for each other. Dealing with the past is never easy and learning new things about your lost loved ones is particularly hard. So many questions, doubts about you know or thought you knew.
Good emotional work.
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
That a was a good and thorough conversation. Liz and Allie are really there for each other. Dealing with the past is never easy and learning new things about your lost loved ones is particularly hard. So many questions, doubts about you know or thought you knew.
Good emotional work.
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Sorry for the cut and paste but I am now currently 158 responses behind. I want to make the changes, thank everyone and start fresh. Wishing you a great day.
Please forgive me for being so far behind on answering reviews, fixing suggestions, and thanking everyone for their kindness. Good thing a birthday only comes once a year. I posted to my family that I was cooking and for the first time in years, my house was over flowing for two days after two days of cooking. Now in three days, Matthew starts filming again and I must cook for them. This woman is tired. Thank you for all your support and kindness.
Smiles, Carol
-
That's okay. You don't have to respond. It is really only expected if someone asks a question.
Enjoy the day off.
-
I like to thank everyone, but this time I am truly overwhelmed. I am down to 40 so things are looking up. LOL Have a great day!
Comment from Sandra Stoner-Mitchell
Oh dear, it's easy to see why she would blame herself, I would have done, too. Although Liz isn't to blame. Now, is Ellie going to te!l her everything about Hope? I do hope so. This was another wonderful part my friend. I'm off to bed now but had to read just part first!! Lots of love and hugs, Sandra xxx
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
Oh dear, it's easy to see why she would blame herself, I would have done, too. Although Liz isn't to blame. Now, is Ellie going to te!l her everything about Hope? I do hope so. This was another wonderful part my friend. I'm off to bed now but had to read just part first!! Lots of love and hugs, Sandra xxx
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Thanks for staying up to read the chapter... Glad it was good then!! I am not caught up yet, but getting closer. I see you are currently in first place for story of the month and it is so deserving. It's an awesome book. Smiles, Carol
-
No we are level pegging with Sally, and you would really deserve to win it, Carol, it's a fabulous book and I'd be the first one to congratulate you. We'll know tomorrow who will win. Good luck!! xxx
-
I hadn't looked lately. When I voted, I most certainly expected to see you in that number one spot. told myself coming in second to you wouldn't bother me a bit...matter of fact, I would consider myself lucky to be ranked that close to your writing. Smiles and hugs!
-
You are so sweet, but there is no way I could compete with you. You're a natural, I have to work at it. Love you lots, dear friend. xxx
-
Oh my goodness now you have doubled over with laughter...That's the English charm and grace flowing across the wide ocean now. I simply love you...You are so good for me. Smiles and hugs forever
-
LOL! You are so sweet, and I love you back. xxxx
Comment from BethShelby
Is there any possiblility that Jack didn't really die? I was wondering if a body was recovered, I imagine Liz would feel guilty if that was the last conversation they ever had. I'm loving all your chapters.
This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
Is there any possiblility that Jack didn't really die? I was wondering if a body was recovered, I imagine Liz would feel guilty if that was the last conversation they ever had. I'm loving all your chapters.
This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Yes, I believe it was mentioned his body was discovered but the wreckage couldn't be removed for several weeks. Thanks so much, Beth
Comment from royowen
It seems Liz blames herself for Jack's death, but somehow I think it's more sinister than that, Jack doesn't seem the type, profile-wise to kill himself, but one never knows. Who is Hope, the sister she hasn't seen? Silly question probably Carol. Allie is a good friend. The report on the crash could prove interesting. Beautifully written, blessings Roy
This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
|
It seems Liz blames herself for Jack's death, but somehow I think it's more sinister than that, Jack doesn't seem the type, profile-wise to kill himself, but one never knows. Who is Hope, the sister she hasn't seen? Silly question probably Carol. Allie is a good friend. The report on the crash could prove interesting. Beautifully written, blessings Roy
This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.
Comment Written 03-Sep-2021
reply by the author on 06-Sep-2021
-
Sorry for the cut and paste but I am now currently 158 responses behind. I want to make the changes, thank everyone and start fresh. Wishing you a great day.
Please forgive me for being so far behind on answering reviews, fixing suggestions, and thanking everyone for their kindness. Good thing a birthday only comes once a year. I posted to my family that I was cooking and for the first time in years, my house was over flowing for two days after two days of cooking. Now in three days, Matthew starts filming again and I must cook for them. This woman is tired. Thank you for all your support and kindness.
Smiles, Carol
