Reviews from

Dear Brother Bill

Short Story

37 total reviews 
Comment from Alaskastory
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

"Dear Brother Bill" has the sound of true experiences and is told with a very appealing portrayal of a real character. This story is a delight to read! So good to see a post by you, Irish. xxx Marie

A missing S: 'three night(s) in a row'

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Wow, thank you for your kind comments, and all those stars! Appreciate your sharp eye, I made that correction.
    Thanks again, irish
Comment from Cian Mateo
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

This was beautifully written with much love and compassion, along with a touch of sadness.

I thoroughly enjoyed your post! And look forward to reading more of your posts.

Cian

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Thank you Cian, for your kind comments, and the stars! Don't post too often, but have past stuff in my portfolio. irish
Comment from Adri7enne
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

What a great story, Irish. It shows the love and respect that existed between the father and son, even after the old man started to forget. The tone is tender, sensitive, replete with love. The ultimate sign of a successful life is to have people love you, right up to the end.

I love the way you put the story together, the way you reveal that the letter is a long-standing ritual between them. You really are a 'devoted romantic.' Always a pleasure to read your work, Irish.

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Ah, thank you, my friend! I sincerely appreciate your insight, comments, and the fantastic rating! Got to admit, I am a hopeless romantic(Sigh!).
    Thanks again, irish
Comment from Writingfundimension
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I love the way you weave the past and present together in this really powerful story, Irish. The letter technique works very well for me, and it provides a poignant look into the past of the old man. Deeply moving, my friend.

:) Bev

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Thank you Bev! Appreciate your kind comments, and the stars!
reply by Writingfundimension on 03-Sep-2014
    You're very welcome, Irish. :)
Comment from granny goes viral
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I absolutely love this. Well constructed. Fast flowing, most importantly (well to me anyway) interesting. A loving picture painted with a loving hand. Good job.

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Ah, thank you, for your kind comments, and all the stars! I like the name you chose for FS, are you really a 'Granny?'
    irish
reply by granny goes viral on 03-Sep-2014
    Are you really Irish?
Comment from sweetwoodjax
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

this si an excellent write, irishauthorme, you did an excellent job portraying the pain of a son watching his father slip away and giving him little doses of comfort to get him to take his pill. I enjoyed reading it.

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Wow, thank you for your kind comments, and the galaxy of stars! Took this from life, needed to write about it.
    Thanks again, irish
Comment from Debra White
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Hello :)
This is such a sad but also heart warming story. Heart warming because of the relationship between the father and son.

In June, my granddad died after having had dementia for around 5 years, he was in a nursing home. Your character Robert Reilly Snr reminded me a lot of my Granddad - at least how he was a year or so ago before the dementia totally robbed us of him.
Your story is very well written. Each character; Robert Snr, Robert, the nurse and also the voice of Robert Snr in his letter of 2005 came across very well - They were real characters not just names in relation to the story.
The twist of the letter actually being written by Robert Snr at the end was clever.
Great use of dialogue, effective scene setting and good pace of story made for an enjoyable read. You have a very engaging writing style.
Kindest regards, Debra :)

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Thank you, Debra, for the stars, and taking the time to read in-depth, and your encouraging review. I can see that you guessed this story was taken from my life, and you were able to understand because of your dear granddad.
    Thanks again, irish
Comment from gypsycaravan
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

If I add two five star ratings together, can I give you a ten? That is the most beautiful and poignant story of an Alzheimer patient I have ever heard or read. I can't thank you enough for writing and posting it. The artwork perfect, also. I liked the twist of him being the writer of the letter and enjoying hearing all the times of his growing up period. I also liked the nurse's compassion and duplicity in the "vitamins." Wonderful work. Congratulations.

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Wow, thank you for your encouraging comments, and the stars! Guess you knew this was taken from real life. I still use the Bushmills as a relaxant in the evenings. :) irish
Comment from Nosha17
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

A very well written story, I liked the inclusion of the letter which added something special to it. Characters were well drawn, narrative flowed, good use of descriptive language and altogether thoroughly charming. I read the bit about Irish whiskey and remembered going to Bushmills Irish Distillery about 2 years ago when we were on a tour of Ireland. I don't drink alcohol really, but sampled a spot of Irish whiskey and found the flavour to be pleasurable. Faye

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Wow, thank you Faye, for your encouraging comments, and the stars! My dream is to visit Ireland, but I am also afraid that I just wouldn't come back.
    Thanks again, irish
Comment from GeraldS
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

This is a well-written 'slice of life' piece. It's a real compliment when your readers assume that what you wrote really wasn't fiction but rather an actual personal experience. My father spent his last four years of life with me, and I have to say that you wrote with an air of authenticity.

 Comment Written 02-Sep-2014


reply by the author on 03-Sep-2014
    Hi Gerald, thank you for your insight, and all those stars! You guessed right, this was taken from my life. Your time with your father gave you a special understanding of this story.
    irish