Reviews from

Water Spirit

1779, Finger Lakes Region of New York

31 total reviews 
Comment from robina1978
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Thanks for your foot note, otherwise I would not have had a clue what you were writing about. This makes it more interesting. So it is near Indians land?

 Comment Written 17-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Ine, and I apologize for writing so 'American'. This whole continent once belonged to the Indians, so for every year in our history, somebody lost land to the Europeans. Few stories are told about the Eastern tribes. Thank you for your interest. Peace, Lee
reply by robina1978 on 17-May-2012
    Welcome Lee, always prepared to learn. Blessings and take care, Ine
Comment from Rob Caudle
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Well you accomplisher your goal. I was there on the shore of the lake in the fog. I found myself wanting turtle to understand that bravery was not there issue but survival. I was told to pop over and give you a read IndianaIrish sent me this way. I owe her a hearty thank you. A really well told tale. I still feel a bit damp from the fog.

Rob

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Rob. I'm delighted you enjoyed my story, and could see through the fog to my point. I appreciate. And I will thank Indy for sending you my way. Peace, Lee
Comment from Cumbrianlass
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

I've said it before and I'll happily repeat myself. You should teach history. You have a way of presenting it that pulls in the human element, the reality of it. It's always a unique angle, putting us in the picture as bystanders, watching what's going on.

Great piece, Lee. I love the references to the Spirit's Handprint. Now I know where the Finger Lakes got their name.

I felt sorry for Hump and totally admired him at the same time. I had to smile at the name you chose for him! ;O)

It's always a pleasure, mon ami.

Av
x

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Av. Actually, I would like to teach history--but always from a personal point of view---history from a pointilist's perspective. I'm delighted you enjoyed. Big Head or Hump, I answer to either. Peace, Lee
Comment from Spitfire
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

A hump-backed protagonist expelled from his world, devoting his life to helping the Indians--outcasts too-- to protect their world. Wonderful build-up of characters, a rhythm that flows like the natural world. Direct dialogue--no words wasted. An awesome story, my friend. Here goes my last six.
xxShari

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Shari, for for your galaxy---and your last one, too. Ever since I read The Leatherstocking Tales this era has fascinated me. The challenge was to come up with a character totally unlike Natty Bumppo. I'm delighted you enjoyed. Thank you again. Peace, Lee
reply by Spitfire on 17-May-2012
    That's a clue to one of your past lives.
Comment from sweetwoodjax
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

this is very well written, humpwhistle, you did a great job writing this story about the fight of the iriquois, i enjoyed reading this and i loved your author notes as well. great imagery and emotion throughout.

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Sweetie. I'm glad you enjoyed. Peace, Lee
Comment from pattipac
Exceptional
This work has reached the exceptional level

To bad you don't write history books. Students wouldn't want to put the book down. Too many dates, too many facts and not enough realism in our books today. Your story of two Indians; one a deformed outcast and the other a leader of a tribe have bonded in an unusual way. Lives are saved because Hump tells the only friend he has of the approaching American army. Well written story. Ever thought about compiling your version of some of our nation's actual history in a book of your own for middle school and/or high school students?

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Patricia. I completely agree with you about the dreariness of our history texts. I like your suggestion of compiling a book. Or even augmenting existing texts by interspersing these 'personal history' stories. Thank you so much for your attention and generosity. Peace, Lee
Comment from N.K. Wagner
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Where is a six when I need it?

Lee, you've made this tiny bit of history a human struggle rather than a military campaign. Defeat on a scale Turtle cannot even imagine is coming and only Big Head sees it. His paddle is as heavy as his heart, but all he can do isn't nearly enough.

You've done a wonderful job setting the scene and building the characters. If they didn't really live somewhere other than in your imagination, they should have.

:) Nancy

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Nancy. Yes, I like this 'pointilist's' view of history---zoom in close and see the dots. I'm so glad you connected the dots. Peace, Lee
Comment from c_lucas
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

The same Indian Nation form of government formed our constitution. This is very well written with a smooth flow of words, making for a very good read.

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Charlie! You know your history, man. Were you there?
    Peace, Lee
reply by c_lucas on 17-May-2012
    You're welcome, Lee. I was a cripple young man with a passion for the written word. Google Tecumseh - The Indian's George Washington -He almost succeeded in uniting the Indians against the whites.
reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Yes, Charlie, we share an affinity for this history. I've read quite a bit about Tecumseh (and his treacherous half-brother). Even before Tecumseh, King Philip of the Wampanoag tried to unite the Eastern tribes, and almost succeeded. So many great stories!
reply by c_lucas on 17-May-2012
    His half brother was jealous, not treacherous.
reply by c_lucas on 17-May-2012
    Check out the Apaches' test for manhood.
reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    I have also read about the Apaches.
    The ultimate warrior.
    Off topic, but I've always been interested in writing a story about the disappearance of the Anasazi. Any insight?
reply by c_lucas on 17-May-2012
    The Anasazi assimilated with other tribes, especially the Zuni and Hopi. They were driven out of existance by the more war-like Navjos and Apache.
reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    I'm not so sure, Charlie. If I'm correct, the Anasazi pre-date those other tribes. It seems more likely that the Zuni and Hopi are distant remnants of the Anasazi.
    I need to brush up on my research. Still, I like the mystery of the disappearance. I'm a romantic at heart.
reply by c_lucas on 17-May-2012
    The Anasazi were first. This may help you.
    http://www.ehow.com/about_5373418_anasazi-indian.html
reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thanks, Charlie. I like a good discussion in the morning. Lee
Comment from MumEsGirl
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Brillaint Lee, I have always loved this period of history. It saddens me that so much wrong was done to people being hounded and banished regularly.

Suppose it reminds me of the plight of the Irish too

hugs
kate

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Kate. This period has fascinated me sine I read The Leatherstocking Tales. These sad stories play themselves out in every land. Thank you again. Peace, Lee
Comment from Phyllis Stewart
Excellent
Not yet exceptional. When the exceptional rating is reached this is highlighted

Very interesting characters you have created for this bit of fiction tied to an actual event. I was not familiar with the story of this tribe so I thank you for posting this story. Good writing throughout.

 Comment Written 16-May-2012


reply by the author on 17-May-2012
    Thank you, Phyllis. The Iroquois Conferderacy was one of the strongest alliances in Eastern America. I'm delighted you enjoyed. Peace, Lee