The Scarlet Letter in A-Z Land
Hester Prynne - the original liberated woman76 total reviews
Comment from Mischief's Momma
You're so right!
When my kids were first assigned this book I read it, as I have many other American classics, and had a much different take on Hester than my children - much more in line with yours.
However the English teacher at my daughter's school was of the same opinion though, so they heard her presented this way.
MM
reply by the author on 04-Jan-2009
  |
You're so right!
When my kids were first assigned this book I read it, as I have many other American classics, and had a much different take on Hester than my children - much more in line with yours.
However the English teacher at my daughter's school was of the same opinion though, so they heard her presented this way.
MM
Comment Written 04-Jan-2009
reply by the author on 04-Jan-2009
-
so much depends on what the teacher thinks - so many present only their own interpretation as if it's the only one available thank you, Brooke
Comment from shy1250
Believe it or not, I've never read The Scarlet Letter. And now, thanx to your "REader's Digest" condensation, I know exactly what happens without reading it still. No suggestions or corrections. Love the alliteration throughout, "Woman X-alted" is fave. Scarlet presentation is perfection! Kudos! later and God bless, shy
reply by the author on 13-Dec-2008
|
Believe it or not, I've never read The Scarlet Letter. And now, thanx to your "REader's Digest" condensation, I know exactly what happens without reading it still. No suggestions or corrections. Love the alliteration throughout, "Woman X-alted" is fave. Scarlet presentation is perfection! Kudos! later and God bless, shy
Comment Written 13-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 13-Dec-2008
-
You just made me laugh! Thanks so much, Brooke
Comment from peggysis64
Brooke, another well written piece you have introduced to A-Z Land. You have done a beautiful job with your description of Hester and her journey. Very vivid, easy read. You have carried me back to hs and I remember my admiration of Hester as she refuses to allow her past to rule her. k
reply by the author on 12-Dec-2008
|
Brooke, another well written piece you have introduced to A-Z Land. You have done a beautiful job with your description of Hester and her journey. Very vivid, easy read. You have carried me back to hs and I remember my admiration of Hester as she refuses to allow her past to rule her. k
Comment Written 12-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 12-Dec-2008
-
thanks so very much - you are a thoughtful reviewer, Brooke
Comment from Freeflyer
What strength of character your subject must have had. You have put together a strong piece of writing. It was directed well and each word shouted out a message. I enjoyed it very much.
Freeflyer
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
|
What strength of character your subject must have had. You have put together a strong piece of writing. It was directed well and each word shouted out a message. I enjoyed it very much.
Freeflyer
Comment Written 10-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
-
thank you so very much- and yes, she appears to have been an exceptionally strong person! Brooke
Comment from Nanny 6
Good morning, Brooke, You portrayed as much emotion in your poem as the book and the movie. Your descriptive words brought out the story in full. Great job! Judy
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
|
Good morning, Brooke, You portrayed as much emotion in your poem as the book and the movie. Your descriptive words brought out the story in full. Great job! Judy
Comment Written 10-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
-
Judy, thanks so much, Brooke
Comment from Annmuma
Great presentation and wonderful flow to the words. They gave a feeling of the witch trials. Appreciate the authors notes as well and the reminder of Hawthorn's Scarlet Letter. enjoyed. ann
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
|
Great presentation and wonderful flow to the words. They gave a feeling of the witch trials. Appreciate the authors notes as well and the reminder of Hawthorn's Scarlet Letter. enjoyed. ann
Comment Written 10-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
-
Ann, I'm so glad you like it -thank you, Brooke
Comment from giftid3
Thank you for your notes giving description to the poem you have compiled. After reading the notes, the poem made so much sense and the words used described well, the life of a woman treated with scorn for her sin and the transformation that took place. She sounds like an amazing woman and one that many of us could take lessons from, to stand against adversity and ridicule, judgment, condemnation and criticism. For me, in the end she was exonerated by God who is the witness of all, and judgment fell on the one to whom it should have been in the first place, considering he stood at the realm as God's representation and head. This reminds me of the adulterous woman in the bible that came before Jesus. Not a stone was cast at her for none was without sin. Mind you, in this case, she was 'stoned' with words and actions but in the end she too was exonerated. Thank you for sharing this and the history lesson given also. I enjoyed it and for me, would have loved to have read more about this courageous woman, who from sinner began, redeemer she became, a blessing to all she met. Many blessings to you
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
|
Thank you for your notes giving description to the poem you have compiled. After reading the notes, the poem made so much sense and the words used described well, the life of a woman treated with scorn for her sin and the transformation that took place. She sounds like an amazing woman and one that many of us could take lessons from, to stand against adversity and ridicule, judgment, condemnation and criticism. For me, in the end she was exonerated by God who is the witness of all, and judgment fell on the one to whom it should have been in the first place, considering he stood at the realm as God's representation and head. This reminds me of the adulterous woman in the bible that came before Jesus. Not a stone was cast at her for none was without sin. Mind you, in this case, she was 'stoned' with words and actions but in the end she too was exonerated. Thank you for sharing this and the history lesson given also. I enjoyed it and for me, would have loved to have read more about this courageous woman, who from sinner began, redeemer she became, a blessing to all she met. Many blessings to you
Comment Written 10-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
-
Yes, she was stoned with words - and still she withstood them - that is true courage - thank you for recognizing that in my poem, Brooke
Comment from TheDon
This is a most difficult form of poetry and you have appeared to master it.
BTW, don't forget about Roger and revenge. That was a big part of the story, too.
I hope this helps and good luck.
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
|
This is a most difficult form of poetry and you have appeared to master it.
BTW, don't forget about Roger and revenge. That was a big part of the story, too.
I hope this helps and good luck.
Comment Written 10-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
-
oh, yes, I know - I can never get the entirety of a story into one of these poems- I choose a focus. But he is not forgotten! Thanks, Brooke
Comment from Hitcher
You have given me flashes of Demi Moore in her prime, Mmmmmmm, The Scarlet letter, a great movie, emotional story and you have offered up another fine piece of work that compliments the power of Hester. Thank you for Demi!
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
|
You have given me flashes of Demi Moore in her prime, Mmmmmmm, The Scarlet letter, a great movie, emotional story and you have offered up another fine piece of work that compliments the power of Hester. Thank you for Demi!
Comment Written 10-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 10-Dec-2008
-
Thanks for your kind reply - I never watched the movie as the critics totally trashed her. So, you think she was good? I have no opinion on the matter. Brooke
Comment from raimie
omg I just bought a new copy of this book at the half price book store, I read my other one to shreds. This is a wonderful adaptation of this story. It is clever enough to be a synopsis. Great job brooke!
reply by the author on 09-Dec-2008
|
omg I just bought a new copy of this book at the half price book store, I read my other one to shreds. This is a wonderful adaptation of this story. It is clever enough to be a synopsis. Great job brooke!
Comment Written 09-Dec-2008
reply by the author on 09-Dec-2008
-
Well, isn't it nice to find another Scarlet Letter fan? Thanks so much as your opinion now counts double!! Brooke
-
Oh, if you ever get time my favorite book of all time is Farenheit 451. I have a 1968 signed copy by Ray Bradbury. Not that you need any suggestions, but it is such a wonderful read :
-
I love that book too - I will add it to my list of requests! that really is lovely that you would like me to give your favorite a try
